Recurrent CAPN3 p.Asp753Asn Variant Supports a Potential Dominant Calpainopathy with Variable Clinical Expressivity

Limb-Girdle Muscular Dystrophies (LGMDs) are genetically heterogeneous disorders primarily affecting proximal limb muscles. The most common form, LGMDR1, results from biallelic CAPN3 mutations encoding calpain-3, a muscle-specific protease. Recently, growing evidence implicates heterozygous CAPN3 variants in autosomal dominant disease (LGMDD4), with pathogenic mechanisms still incompletely understood. In a retrospective multicenter Italian study of patients harboring monoallelic CAPN3 variants (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT05956132), the p.Asp753Asn substitution was the most frequent change, detected in eight unrelated individuals. These patients, aged 6–80 years, exhibited a spectrum of presentations ranging from asymptomatic hyperCKemia and exertional myalgia to mild proximal weakness. Muscle biopsies showed mild, nonspecific myopathic changes, while calpain-3 expression was variably reduced. Structural modeling suggested that Asp753 may stabilize the Ca2+-bound conformation, with substitution potentially disrupting inter-domain interactions. Literature review identified 31 additional reports worldwide, confirming recurrence while highlighting marked phenotypic heterogeneity and limited clinical annotation. The aggregated evidence supports a pathogenic role for p.Asp753Asn, though the precise mechanism, potentially involving a dominant-negative effect, remains to be validated. These findings emphasize diagnostic challenges posed by single CAPN3 variants and underscore the need for integrated clinical, segregation, and functional studies to clarify pathogenic mechanisms, refine counseling, and guide patient-specific rehabilitation and therapeutic strategies.