Objective: To assess the performance of a morphological evaluation, based on a clinically relevant magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) protocol, in scoring the severity of knee cartilage damage. Specifically, to evaluate the reproducibility, repeatability, and agreement of MRI evaluation with the gross pathology examination (GPE) of the tissue. Methods: MRI of the knee was performed the day before surgery in 23 patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty. Osteochondral tissue resections were collected and chondral defects were scored by GPE according to a semi-quantitative scale. MR images were independently scored by four radiologists, who assessed the severity of chondral damage according to equivalent criteria. Inter- and intra-rater agreements of MRI evaluations were assessed. Correlation, precision, and accuracy metrics between MRI and GPE scores were calculated. Results: Moderate to substantial inter-rater agreement in scoring cartilage damage by MRI was found among radiologists. Intra-rater agreement was higher than 96%. A significant positive monotonic correlation between GPE and MRI scores was observed for all radiologists, although higher correlation values were obtained by radiologists with expertise in musculoskeletal radiology and/or longer experience. The accuracy of MRI scores displayed a spatial pattern, characterized by lesion overestimation in the lateral condyle and underestimation in the medial condyle with respect to GPE. Conclusions: Evaluation of knee cartilage morphology by MRI is a reproducible and repeatable technique, which positively correlates with GPE. Clinical expertise in musculoskeletal radiology positively impacts the evaluation reliability. These findings may help to address limitations in MRI evaluation of knee chondral lesions, thus improving MRI assessment of knee cartilage. Key Points: • MRI evaluation of knee cartilage shows moderate to strong correlation with gross pathology examination. • MRI evaluation overestimates cartilage damage in the lateral condyle and underestimates it in the medial condyle. • Education and experience of the radiologist play a role in MRI evaluation of knee chondral lesions.

Morphological MRI of knee cartilage: repeatability and reproducibility of damage evaluation and correlation with gross pathology examination / A. Marinetti, F. Tessarolo, L. Ventura, A. Falzone, M. Neri, F. Piccoli, M. Rigoni, M. Mase, F. Cortese, G. Nollo, S.W. Della Sala. - In: EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY. - ISSN 0938-7994. - 30:6(2020), pp. 3226-3235. [10.1007/s00330-019-06627-5]

Morphological MRI of knee cartilage: repeatability and reproducibility of damage evaluation and correlation with gross pathology examination

M. Rigoni;
2020

Abstract

Objective: To assess the performance of a morphological evaluation, based on a clinically relevant magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) protocol, in scoring the severity of knee cartilage damage. Specifically, to evaluate the reproducibility, repeatability, and agreement of MRI evaluation with the gross pathology examination (GPE) of the tissue. Methods: MRI of the knee was performed the day before surgery in 23 patients undergoing total knee arthroplasty. Osteochondral tissue resections were collected and chondral defects were scored by GPE according to a semi-quantitative scale. MR images were independently scored by four radiologists, who assessed the severity of chondral damage according to equivalent criteria. Inter- and intra-rater agreements of MRI evaluations were assessed. Correlation, precision, and accuracy metrics between MRI and GPE scores were calculated. Results: Moderate to substantial inter-rater agreement in scoring cartilage damage by MRI was found among radiologists. Intra-rater agreement was higher than 96%. A significant positive monotonic correlation between GPE and MRI scores was observed for all radiologists, although higher correlation values were obtained by radiologists with expertise in musculoskeletal radiology and/or longer experience. The accuracy of MRI scores displayed a spatial pattern, characterized by lesion overestimation in the lateral condyle and underestimation in the medial condyle with respect to GPE. Conclusions: Evaluation of knee cartilage morphology by MRI is a reproducible and repeatable technique, which positively correlates with GPE. Clinical expertise in musculoskeletal radiology positively impacts the evaluation reliability. These findings may help to address limitations in MRI evaluation of knee chondral lesions, thus improving MRI assessment of knee cartilage. Key Points: • MRI evaluation of knee cartilage shows moderate to strong correlation with gross pathology examination. • MRI evaluation overestimates cartilage damage in the lateral condyle and underestimates it in the medial condyle. • Education and experience of the radiologist play a role in MRI evaluation of knee chondral lesions.
Articular cartilage; Knee; Magnetic resonance imaging; Aged; Aged; 80 and over; Cartilage Diseases; Cartilage; Articular; Female; Humans; Knee Joint; Magnetic Resonance Imaging; Male; Middle Aged; Reproducibility of Results
Settore MED/01 - Statistica Medica
Article (author)
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Marinetti_et_al-2020-European_Radiology.pdf

accesso riservato

Tipologia: Publisher's version/PDF
Dimensione 1.28 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
1.28 MB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2434/936581
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? 4
  • Scopus 6
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? 7
social impact