The present essay aims at analysing the development of the integration process between the legal and judicial systems of Italy and the European Union, especially looking at the building of a dialogue in which the main Courts of both institutional realities should play a decisive role. An initial glance will be drawn on the controversial origins of the relation between the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and the Italian Constitutional Court (ICC), looking at some important judgements that have been pronounced in this context (particularly, Simmenthal of the CJEU and Granital of the ICC). Then, some attention will be given to the birth of the counter-limits doctrine in the jurisprudence of the ICC and the influence it had (and could have) on a new legal order that binds together national constitutionalism and fundamental principles of EU law. Finally, moving from a short analysis of the Taricco case(s), the author will try to understand how far the interrelation between Italian and EU judicial systems has gone, dealing with a contemporary reality where the idea of a united Europe seems threatened by the rise of nationalism and populism.

Corte costituzionale italiana y doctrina de los contralímites: el (dificil) camino hacia una plena integración jurídica europea = Italian constitutional Court and the counter-limits doctrine: the (difficult) path towards a full legal European integration / D. Camoni. - In: REVISTA DE ESTUDIOS EUROPEOS. - ISSN 2530-9854. - 75(2020), pp. 165-178. (Intervento presentato al convegno II Congreso internacional de jóvenes investigadores sobre la Unión europea tenutosi a Valladolid nel 2019).

Corte costituzionale italiana y doctrina de los contralímites: el (dificil) camino hacia una plena integración jurídica europea = Italian constitutional Court and the counter-limits doctrine: the (difficult) path towards a full legal European integration

D. Camoni
2020

Abstract

The present essay aims at analysing the development of the integration process between the legal and judicial systems of Italy and the European Union, especially looking at the building of a dialogue in which the main Courts of both institutional realities should play a decisive role. An initial glance will be drawn on the controversial origins of the relation between the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and the Italian Constitutional Court (ICC), looking at some important judgements that have been pronounced in this context (particularly, Simmenthal of the CJEU and Granital of the ICC). Then, some attention will be given to the birth of the counter-limits doctrine in the jurisprudence of the ICC and the influence it had (and could have) on a new legal order that binds together national constitutionalism and fundamental principles of EU law. Finally, moving from a short analysis of the Taricco case(s), the author will try to understand how far the interrelation between Italian and EU judicial systems has gone, dealing with a contemporary reality where the idea of a united Europe seems threatened by the rise of nationalism and populism.
El presente articulo tiene como objetivo reflexionar sobre el desarrollo del proceso de integración entre los ordenamientos jurídicos italiano y europeo, en particular a través de la construcción de un diálogo – no siempre fácil y distendido – que asuma como protagonistas las respectivas instituciones jurisdiccionales. Por esta razón, en primer lugar se abordarán los conflictivos orígenes de la relación entre el Tribunal de Justicia de la Comunidad/Unión europea y la Corte costituzionale, recordando en breve algunas sentencias fundamentales (Simmenthal del TJUE y Granital de la Corte). A seguir, se prestará atención a la elaboración conceptual de la teoría de los contralímites por parte del Juez constitucional italiano y a la influencia de la misma en la plasmación de un (nuevo) orden jurídico integrado, que aglutine constitucionalismo “nacional” y principios supremos comunitarios. Finalmente, se tratarán los recientes acontecimientos de la “saga Taricco” para esbozar algunas consideraciones sobre el grado de compenetración hoy en día existente entre derecho italiano y derecho de la Unión europea, en un horizonte político-institucional general en el cual los cimientos de la unidad europea parecen tambalearse en favor de un aislamiento nacional (y nacionalista) cada vez más pronunciado.
Italian Constitutional Court; Court of Justice of the European Union; counter-limits; fundamental principles; European integration
Settore IUS/21 - Diritto Pubblico Comparato
Settore IUS/08 - Diritto Costituzionale
Settore IUS/14 - Diritto dell'Unione Europea
2020
Instituto de estudios europeos
https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/articulo?codigo=7216848
Article (author)
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Corte costituzionale e controlimiti (Revista de Estudios Europeos, 75-2020).pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia: Publisher's version/PDF
Dimensione 87.44 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
87.44 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2434/921458
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact