In the Italian legal system, traditionally based on the prominence of the public interest, there has been a tendency to attribute a growing relevance to the interests of individuals. Therefore, nowadays it is necessary to reach a balance between the latter and the public interest, which has to be fulfilled by both administrative and political activity. In this context, it is possible to analyze the phenomenon of lobbying, taking into account the close correlation - initially understood, rather, as a clear contrast - between public interest and lobbying activities. Although such correlation should have resulted in a deepening understanding by administrative law, in Italy the phenomenon of lobbies has remained in a grey area and has not been investigated in-depth by administrative law doctrine. In fact, the historically disadvantage of these interest groups has led to the absence of a legal framework, leaving lobbying outside the legal world and, so, allowing that the influence of interest groups could lead to corruption, subject to criminal sanctions. After outlining the strict relationship between public interest and interest groups, the paper means to investigate the need to introduce a regulation of lobbying in Italian law and to understand whether or not the regulations adopted by some Italian authorities could be a first stone in the drafting of a legal regime.

Opacity in the Italian decision-making process : Lobbying and its lack of legal framework / E. Romani - In: La discrétion / [a cura di] F. Barviaux , Y. Le Foulgoc , P. Lazzarotto. - Paris : Mare & Martin, 2022. - ISBN 978-2-84934-642-6. - pp. 175-193 (( Intervento presentato al 7. convegno La discrétion tenutosi a Strasbourg nel 2019.

Opacity in the Italian decision-making process : Lobbying and its lack of legal framework

E. Romani
2022

Abstract

In the Italian legal system, traditionally based on the prominence of the public interest, there has been a tendency to attribute a growing relevance to the interests of individuals. Therefore, nowadays it is necessary to reach a balance between the latter and the public interest, which has to be fulfilled by both administrative and political activity. In this context, it is possible to analyze the phenomenon of lobbying, taking into account the close correlation - initially understood, rather, as a clear contrast - between public interest and lobbying activities. Although such correlation should have resulted in a deepening understanding by administrative law, in Italy the phenomenon of lobbies has remained in a grey area and has not been investigated in-depth by administrative law doctrine. In fact, the historically disadvantage of these interest groups has led to the absence of a legal framework, leaving lobbying outside the legal world and, so, allowing that the influence of interest groups could lead to corruption, subject to criminal sanctions. After outlining the strict relationship between public interest and interest groups, the paper means to investigate the need to introduce a regulation of lobbying in Italian law and to understand whether or not the regulations adopted by some Italian authorities could be a first stone in the drafting of a legal regime.
Dans le système juridique italien, traditionnellement basé sur la prééminence de l'intérêt public, le phénomène des lobbies est resté dans une zone grise et n'a pas été étudié en profondeur par la doctrine du droit administratif. Alors qu'en France a été adoptée la loi Sapin II du 9 décembre 2016 sur la transparence, ce cadre commun qui prend en compte les influences et les relations entre les groupes d'intérêt et le Parlement n’a pas encore été introduit en Italie. La présente étude porte sur la nécessité d'introduire une réglementation du lobbying dans le droit italien et cherche à comprendre si une telle réglementation, adoptée jusqu'à présent par certaines autorités italiennes, pourrait être une première pierre dans l'élaboration d'un régime juridique. En outre, elle s’attarde sur l'opportunité d'indiquer une autorité publique responsable de la mise en œuvre d'une telle réglementation. Ce pouvoir de contrôle devrait être attribué à l'Autorité italienne de lutte contre la corruption puisque les activités de lobbying sont souvent opaques et peuvent masquer des phénomènes de corruption ou des pressions illicites qui sapent la légitimité des procédures législatives ou administratives.
lobbying; decision-making process; public interest; register for lobbyists; Italian Anticorruption Authority; ANAC
Settore IUS/10 - Diritto Amministrativo
2022
Université de Strasbourg
Book Part (author)
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Opacity in Italian decision-making process - E. Romani.pdf

accesso riservato

Tipologia: Publisher's version/PDF
Dimensione 425.46 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
425.46 kB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2434/801910
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact