Does Hegel’s philosophical interpretation actually show a propensity to set aside the concrete life of Socrates, the man, in favor of a presumedly immortal and impersonal saga of the spirit? Assuming a perspective that, by a certain methodological epoché, brackets the complex set of problems regarding the relationship between history and thought in the all-encompassing realm of the spirit, our interpretation nevertheless aims, in some respects, to fill in the picture and to suggest some aspects to reflect in relation to the problem. In fact, our main contention is that Socrates is indeed read by Hegel within the context of the history of philosophy (i.e. the form of thought), but also in analogy to a tragic work of art, that is in relation to another area of the spirit and of its complexity. After having presented what we term the “dialectical drama of Socrates”, we will delve into the Socratic method, its form, content and execution, according to Hegel, in order to flesh out the hypothesis set forth above. By way of conclusion, we will provide some brief remarks on the Hegelian conception of the spirit in relation to the principle of interiority, represented by the figure of Socrates, and, in particular, subverting a prominent topos that likens Socrates to Christ, we will interpose the mediating figure of Adam.

El Sócrates de Hegel: héroe del espíritu y obra de arte trágica / L. Manfrini - In: Sócrates, el enigma de Atenas / Ó.M. Donato, G. Meléndez, A. Lozano Vásquez, D. Amat, L. Manfrini, F. Rojas. - Prima edizione. - Bogotà : Universidad Libre, 2015 Aug. - ISBN 9789588791807. - pp. 89-140

El Sócrates de Hegel: héroe del espíritu y obra de arte trágica

L. Manfrini
Primo
2015

Abstract

Does Hegel’s philosophical interpretation actually show a propensity to set aside the concrete life of Socrates, the man, in favor of a presumedly immortal and impersonal saga of the spirit? Assuming a perspective that, by a certain methodological epoché, brackets the complex set of problems regarding the relationship between history and thought in the all-encompassing realm of the spirit, our interpretation nevertheless aims, in some respects, to fill in the picture and to suggest some aspects to reflect in relation to the problem. In fact, our main contention is that Socrates is indeed read by Hegel within the context of the history of philosophy (i.e. the form of thought), but also in analogy to a tragic work of art, that is in relation to another area of the spirit and of its complexity. After having presented what we term the “dialectical drama of Socrates”, we will delve into the Socratic method, its form, content and execution, according to Hegel, in order to flesh out the hypothesis set forth above. By way of conclusion, we will provide some brief remarks on the Hegelian conception of the spirit in relation to the principle of interiority, represented by the figure of Socrates, and, in particular, subverting a prominent topos that likens Socrates to Christ, we will interpose the mediating figure of Adam.
¿Requiere en verdad la interpretación filosófica de Hegel olvidarse de la vida concreta de Sócrates, el hombre, para favorecer una presunta leyenda inmortal del espíritu impersonal? Colocándose, con una cierta epojé metodológica, fuera de la grave problemática sobre las relaciones entre historia y pensamiento en el ámbito omnicomprensivo del espíritu, nuestra interpretación quiere, en cierto modo, agravar el cuadro y ofrecer elementos de reflexión conectados con esta problemática. De hecho, nuestra tesis principal es que Sócrates es leído por Hegel dentro de la historia de la filosofía (es decir, bajo la forma del pensamiento), pero también en analogía a una obra de arte trágica, o sea, en relación con otro ámbito del espíritu y de su complejidad. Después de haber presentado lo que queremos llamar el “drama dialéctico de Sócrates”, profundizando en el método socrático, su forma y contenido, y su desarrollo, según Hegel, explicaremos nuestra tesis, antes expuesta. Para concluir desarrollaremos pequeñas notas sobre la concepción hegeliana del espíritu en relación con el principio de la interioridad que la figura de Sócrates manifestaría; en particular, subvirtiendo un ilustre topos que ve acercar a Sócrates y Cristo, introduciremos entre los dos la mediación de Adán.
Historia de la filosofía; historia del espíritu; héroe del espíritu; drama dialéctico; obra de arte trágica; principio interior del conocimiento; Cristo; Adán
Settore M-FIL/01 - Filosofia Teoretica
Settore M-FIL/06 - Storia della Filosofia
Settore M-FIL/03 - Filosofia Morale
Settore M-FIL/04 - Estetica
ago-2015
Book Part (author)
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Sócrates.pdf

accesso riservato

Descrizione: Volume intero
Tipologia: Publisher's version/PDF
Dimensione 4.73 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
4.73 MB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2434/340119
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact