Urban soil multifunctionality and seasonal variability of carbon-linked soil traits

Urban soils can play a significant role in climate change mitigation due to their capacity to store carbon (C) and support microbial biodiversity. In this context, this study evaluated the effects of different fertilization strategies on soil quality, greenhouse gas emissions, and microbial communities in two urban green areas located in the Campania region (Southern Italy) over a three-year period. Mineral fertilization (MIN), micronized vermicompost (CMP), micronized biochar (BCH), vermicompost plus biochar (CMP + BCH) were compared to an unfertilized control (CNT). The results showed that soil physicochemical properties were mainly influenced by site-specific conditions and temporal variability, whereas cation exchange capacity was the soil parameter most responsive to fertilization treatments. The QBS-ar index, used as an indicator of soil biological quality based on soil arthropods, was primarily affected by seasonality, with higher values recorded during spring–summer and no significant effects attributable to fertilization treatments. Vermicompost, BCH, and their combination were associated with lower net soil–vegetation CO2 fluxes and smaller temporal increases in the measured flux compared with the control and mineral fertilization treatments. All treatments exhibited a negative estimated annualized net C balance, indicating that, under the adopted temporal upscaling procedure, the estimated gaseous exchanges exceeded the annual increase in soil organic carbon stocks. Nevertheless, BCH showed the least negative estimated annualized balance. Analyses of microbial diversity revealed that bacterial and fungal communities were mainly shaped by temporal and seasonal factors, while fertilization treatments had limited effects on microbial diversity and community composition. Overall, the findings indicate that biochar showed the most favorable estimated carbon balance and the lowest measured net CO2 fluxes under the conditions investigated. However, its effects on soil biological and microbial properties were limited in the short term, and none of the tested treatments achieved net carbon sequestration. These results suggest that biochar may contribute to climate change mitigation as part of long-term, site-specific management strategies rather than as a standalone solution for improving soil multifunctionality.