The increasing use of algorithms in public administration raises significant legal challenges, particularly regarding the risk of discrimination resulting from data-driven decision-making. This article explores the structural relationship between algorithms and data, highlighting how biases embedded in datasets may be reproduced and amplified through automated administrative decisions. Drawing on the Italian case of the “Good School” algorithm and other examples of automated decision-making in the allocation of public benefits, the study shows how algorithmic governance may generate discriminatory outcomes, especially in sensitive areas such as access to social assistance. The paper examines the role of algorithmic transparency and the duty to give reasons as key legal safeguards to ensure the legality, accountability, and reviewability of automated administrative decisions. It also analyses the contribution of European Union law—particularly the Charter of Fundamental Rights and the EU Artificial Intelligence Regulation—in establishing a regulatory framework aimed at preventing algorithmic discrimination. The article concludes by emphasising the central role of administrative law in guiding and regulating the use of algorithms within public administration in order to safeguard fundamental rights and uphold the right to good administration

Decisión administrativa algorítmica discriminatoria y datos: reflexiones y propuestas = Discriminatory Algorithmic Administrative Decision-Making and Data: Reflections and Proposals / D.U. Galetta. - In: REVISTA DE PRIVACIDAD, INNOVACIÓN Y TECNOLOGÍA. - 2026:1(2026), pp. 12-26.

Decisión administrativa algorítmica discriminatoria y datos: reflexiones y propuestas = Discriminatory Algorithmic Administrative Decision-Making and Data: Reflections and Proposals

D.U. Galetta
2026

Abstract

The increasing use of algorithms in public administration raises significant legal challenges, particularly regarding the risk of discrimination resulting from data-driven decision-making. This article explores the structural relationship between algorithms and data, highlighting how biases embedded in datasets may be reproduced and amplified through automated administrative decisions. Drawing on the Italian case of the “Good School” algorithm and other examples of automated decision-making in the allocation of public benefits, the study shows how algorithmic governance may generate discriminatory outcomes, especially in sensitive areas such as access to social assistance. The paper examines the role of algorithmic transparency and the duty to give reasons as key legal safeguards to ensure the legality, accountability, and reviewability of automated administrative decisions. It also analyses the contribution of European Union law—particularly the Charter of Fundamental Rights and the EU Artificial Intelligence Regulation—in establishing a regulatory framework aimed at preventing algorithmic discrimination. The article concludes by emphasising the central role of administrative law in guiding and regulating the use of algorithms within public administration in order to safeguard fundamental rights and uphold the right to good administration
El uso de algoritmos en la actividad de las administraciones públicas plantea importantes desafíos jurídicos, especialmente en relación con el riesgo de discriminación derivado del tratamiento de datos. Este trabajo analiza la relación estructural entre algoritmos y datos, subrayando cómo los sesgos presentes en los conjuntos de datos pueden reproducirse y amplificarse en los procesos de toma de decisiones automatizados. A partir del análisis del caso italiano del algoritmo de la «Buena Escuela» y de otros ejemplos de decisiones administrativas basadas en sistemas automatizados, el artículo muestra cómo la automatización puede generar efectos discriminatorios, especialmente en ámbitos sensibles como la asignación de recursos públicos o prestaciones sociales. El estudio examina el papel de la transparencia algorítmica y de la obligación de motivación como instrumentos esenciales para garantizar la legalidad, la controlabilidad y la legitimidad de las decisiones administrativas automatizadas. Asimismo, se destaca la contribución del Derecho de la Unión Europea, en particular la Carta de los Derechos Fundamentales y el Reglamento de IA, en la construcción de un marco normativo destinado a prevenir la discriminación algorítmica. El artículo concluye subrayando la función central del Derecho administrativo en la regulación y orientación del uso de algoritmos en la administración pública, con el objetivo de garantizar el respeto de los derechos fundamentales y el derecho a una buena administración.
Algoritmos; Discriminación; Transparencia; Datos; Administración; Algorithms; Discrimination; Transparency; Data; Administration;
Settore GIUR-06/A - Diritto amministrativo e pubblico
2026
Article (author)
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
RPIT_01_2026_GALETTA.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia: Publisher's version/PDF
Licenza: Creative commons
Dimensione 429.41 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
429.41 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I metadati presenti in AIR sono rilasciati con licenza CCO mentre i file delle pubblicazioni sono rilasciati con licenza CC BY-SA, salvo diversa indicazione. In caso di violazione di copyright, contattare l'assistenza di AIR

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2434/1246735
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
  • OpenAlex ND
social impact