The article analyzes the complex issue of State aid by looking at its founding elements as well as at the control procedure of the European Commission on these aids. At the first, it recalls the definition of "State aid" developed by the Commission and the EU Court of Justice through an analysis system (the so-called "VIST" criterion) based on the four parameters: (i) economic advantage in favor of a company receiving the public measure; (ii) incidence of a similar measure in the European internal trade; (iii) the selectivity or specificity of the aid; (iv) transfer of state resources. After, the analysis focuses on the control procedure of the European Commission and shows that in certain cases it is particularly complex to place certain support measures in this category. In this sense the recent decisions of the Court of the European Union in cases T-607/17, T-716/17, and T-8/18 and the V section of the Council of State, July 15, 2019, n. 4962 are emblematic. These cases, where there are forms of aid of a new institution represented by a regulatory intervention adopted at regional level, offer the opportunity to highlight that the EU legislation cannot be circumvented.

La (recente) giurisprudenza interna ed eurounitaria sul tema degli aiuti di Stato. Uno sguardo agli aiuti istituiti con legge regionale, in particolare, alla vicenda degli aeroporti sardi = The (recent) domestic and European Union case-law on State aids. A look at the domestic aids established by regional laws, in particular the Sardinian airports case / V. Sordi. - In: DIRITTO E POLITICA DEI TRASPORTI. - ISSN 2612-5056. - 4:6 (I)(2021), pp. 22-37.

La (recente) giurisprudenza interna ed eurounitaria sul tema degli aiuti di Stato. Uno sguardo agli aiuti istituiti con legge regionale, in particolare, alla vicenda degli aeroporti sardi = The (recent) domestic and European Union case-law on State aids. A look at the domestic aids established by regional laws, in particular the Sardinian airports case.

V. Sordi
2021

Abstract

The article analyzes the complex issue of State aid by looking at its founding elements as well as at the control procedure of the European Commission on these aids. At the first, it recalls the definition of "State aid" developed by the Commission and the EU Court of Justice through an analysis system (the so-called "VIST" criterion) based on the four parameters: (i) economic advantage in favor of a company receiving the public measure; (ii) incidence of a similar measure in the European internal trade; (iii) the selectivity or specificity of the aid; (iv) transfer of state resources. After, the analysis focuses on the control procedure of the European Commission and shows that in certain cases it is particularly complex to place certain support measures in this category. In this sense the recent decisions of the Court of the European Union in cases T-607/17, T-716/17, and T-8/18 and the V section of the Council of State, July 15, 2019, n. 4962 are emblematic. These cases, where there are forms of aid of a new institution represented by a regulatory intervention adopted at regional level, offer the opportunity to highlight that the EU legislation cannot be circumvented.
aiuti di Stato; concorrenza; procedimento di controllo della Commissione UE; principio de minimis; General Block Exemption Regulation; principio della compensatory justification; principio del legittimo affidamento;
Settore GIUR-06/A - Diritto amministrativo e pubblico
2021
Article (author)
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Veronica Sordi - Diritto-e-politica-dei-trasporti - I-2021.pdf

accesso aperto

Tipologia: Publisher's version/PDF
Dimensione 3.27 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
3.27 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2434/1141215
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact