The profound transformations that have affected migrant labour in a global scenario dominated by the neo-liberal paradigm have brought to light systemic exploitative practices. The increasing deregulation and precariousness of the labour market and the vulnerability of male and female migrant workers have affected extremely differentiated production sectors and markets - from agriculture to domestic care services, from tourism to logistics, from construction to catering, from cleaning to home delivery of goods, first and foremost food - with varying degrees of intensity. In these sectors, forms of recruitment, management and control of the labour force inspired by a predatory logic emerge, with a limited consideration of the needs and fundamental rights of the people involved, which enhance an overall deterioration of their conditions of existence. Reference is here made to the fact that although these workers are formally free to accept specific working arrangements, they are de facto pushed by their condition of existential, social, legal and economic vulnerability towards jobs where their agency is often undermined, while opportunities for a positive change are extremely limited. With few exceptions, these are jobs that do not require a high level of qualification and where the body - with its related material and symbolic value – not only becomes the main means of production subject to such an intensive use that sometimes leads to exhaustion, but also a place where multiple social relations are condensed. This article provides an explorative qualitative analysis of the living and working conditions of migrant workers within two distinct labour markets and different geographical contexts that present forms, sometimes particularly extreme, of exploitation: farmework in the greenhouses of the area of Ragusa in Sicily and food delivery in Milan. Based on an extensive fieldwork carried out in 2023-2024 through in-depth interviews with workers, union members and other privileged observers, the study proposes a comparative multi-sited analysis developed along three closely interrelated lines: (i) the correspondences existing between market developments and social composition of the workforce; (ii) the recruitment patterns carried out by both farm employers and food delivery platforms; and (iii) the link between work and health, paying specific attention to the psycho-physical effects that highly exploitative employment and living conditions may impose on migrant bodies. Interesting similarities emerge between the two fields of research related, inter alia, to the conditions of subordination, marginalization, and segregation experienced by migrant workers employed into these two markets, alongside counter-intuitive divergences related to the different strategies of survival and resistance carried out by them, often supported by associations, unions, and groups of citizens active in these areas, which enrich the scholarly debate on the forms of subordination and exploitation imposed by neoliberal capitalism, suggesting further research agendas.

Il contributo intende analizzare le condizioni di vita di lavoratori e lavoratrici migranti all’interno di due distinti mercati del lavoro e differenti contesti geografici che, pur mantenendo le rispettive peculiarità, presentano forme, talvolta particolarmente estreme, di sfruttamento: il lavoro agricolo nelle serre del ragusano e il food delivery a Milano. L’articolo si inserisce all’interno del dibattito scientifico sulle forme di subordinazione e sfruttamento imposte dal capitalismo neoliberista e, prendendo le mosse da una visione che cerca di superare una lettura esclusivamente economica di questi processi, esplora tre direttrici analitiche tra loro strettamente connesse: i) le modalità di reclutamento della forza lavoro migrante nei due settori e territori presi in esame; ii) le forme di invisibilizzazione, materiale e simbolica, agite e/o subite dai lavoratori/trici coinvolti/e; iii) il rapporto tra lavoro e salute, ossia gli effetti psico-fisici sui corpi migranti in corrispondenza di condizioni di impiego e di vita spesso estremamente precarie.

Corpi migranti al lavoro : Forme di sfruttamento e processi di (in)visibilizzazione dalle campagne siciliane alle piattaforme digitali / F. Cabras, L. DI CATALDO, M. Massari. - In: WELFARE E ERGONOMIA. - ISSN 2421-3691. - 2024:1(2024), pp. 27-41. [10.3280/WE2024-001003]

Corpi migranti al lavoro : Forme di sfruttamento e processi di (in)visibilizzazione dalle campagne siciliane alle piattaforme digitali

F. Cabras
Writing – Original Draft Preparation
;
L. DI CATALDO
Writing – Original Draft Preparation
;
M. Massari
Writing – Original Draft Preparation
2024

Abstract

The profound transformations that have affected migrant labour in a global scenario dominated by the neo-liberal paradigm have brought to light systemic exploitative practices. The increasing deregulation and precariousness of the labour market and the vulnerability of male and female migrant workers have affected extremely differentiated production sectors and markets - from agriculture to domestic care services, from tourism to logistics, from construction to catering, from cleaning to home delivery of goods, first and foremost food - with varying degrees of intensity. In these sectors, forms of recruitment, management and control of the labour force inspired by a predatory logic emerge, with a limited consideration of the needs and fundamental rights of the people involved, which enhance an overall deterioration of their conditions of existence. Reference is here made to the fact that although these workers are formally free to accept specific working arrangements, they are de facto pushed by their condition of existential, social, legal and economic vulnerability towards jobs where their agency is often undermined, while opportunities for a positive change are extremely limited. With few exceptions, these are jobs that do not require a high level of qualification and where the body - with its related material and symbolic value – not only becomes the main means of production subject to such an intensive use that sometimes leads to exhaustion, but also a place where multiple social relations are condensed. This article provides an explorative qualitative analysis of the living and working conditions of migrant workers within two distinct labour markets and different geographical contexts that present forms, sometimes particularly extreme, of exploitation: farmework in the greenhouses of the area of Ragusa in Sicily and food delivery in Milan. Based on an extensive fieldwork carried out in 2023-2024 through in-depth interviews with workers, union members and other privileged observers, the study proposes a comparative multi-sited analysis developed along three closely interrelated lines: (i) the correspondences existing between market developments and social composition of the workforce; (ii) the recruitment patterns carried out by both farm employers and food delivery platforms; and (iii) the link between work and health, paying specific attention to the psycho-physical effects that highly exploitative employment and living conditions may impose on migrant bodies. Interesting similarities emerge between the two fields of research related, inter alia, to the conditions of subordination, marginalization, and segregation experienced by migrant workers employed into these two markets, alongside counter-intuitive divergences related to the different strategies of survival and resistance carried out by them, often supported by associations, unions, and groups of citizens active in these areas, which enrich the scholarly debate on the forms of subordination and exploitation imposed by neoliberal capitalism, suggesting further research agendas.
Il contributo intende analizzare le condizioni di vita di lavoratori e lavoratrici migranti all’interno di due distinti mercati del lavoro e differenti contesti geografici che, pur mantenendo le rispettive peculiarità, presentano forme, talvolta particolarmente estreme, di sfruttamento: il lavoro agricolo nelle serre del ragusano e il food delivery a Milano. L’articolo si inserisce all’interno del dibattito scientifico sulle forme di subordinazione e sfruttamento imposte dal capitalismo neoliberista e, prendendo le mosse da una visione che cerca di superare una lettura esclusivamente economica di questi processi, esplora tre direttrici analitiche tra loro strettamente connesse: i) le modalità di reclutamento della forza lavoro migrante nei due settori e territori presi in esame; ii) le forme di invisibilizzazione, materiale e simbolica, agite e/o subite dai lavoratori/trici coinvolti/e; iii) il rapporto tra lavoro e salute, ossia gli effetti psico-fisici sui corpi migranti in corrispondenza di condizioni di impiego e di vita spesso estremamente precarie.
Migration; exploitation; agriculture; food delivery; bodies
Settore GSPS-05/A - Sociologia generale
Settore GSPS-08/A - Sociologia dei processi economici e del lavoro
   Mobilities, solidarities and imaginaries across the borders: the mountain, the sea, the urban and the rural as spaces of transit and encounters.
   MOBS
   MINISTERO DELL'ISTRUZIONE E DEL MERITO
   2020TELSM8_002
2024
Article (author)
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Welfare & Ergonomia_1_2024.pdf

accesso riservato

Tipologia: Publisher's version/PDF
Dimensione 818.93 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
818.93 kB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2434/1118997
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact