Lies tell the truth about cognitive dysfunction in essential tremor : an experimental deception study with the guilty knowledge task

Background: Research conducted in the past decade challenges the traditional view that essential tremor (ET) is characterised exclusively by movement disorder, and increasingly shows that these patients have deficits in cognitive and behavioural functioning. The available evidence suggests that this impairment might arise from dysfunction in either the fronto-subcortical or corticocerebellar circuits. Although abnormalities in the frontosubcortical circuits could imply difficulty in lying, no study has investigated deception in patients with ET. Aims: To examine the cognitive functions regulating deception in patients with ET, we used a computerised task, the Guilty Knowledge Task (GKT). We also tested a group of patients with Parkinson's disease (PD), a disease associated with a known difficulty in lie production, and a group of healthy subjects (HS). Results: In the GKT for deception, patients with ET responded less accurately than HS (p=0.014) but similarly to patients with PD (p=0.955). No differences between groups were found in truthful responses (p=0.488). Conclusions: Besides confirming impaired deception in patients with PD, our results show a lie production deficit in patients with ET also. These findings suggest that difficulty in lying is an aspecific cognitive feature in movement disorders characterised by fronto-subcortical circuit dysfunction, such as PD and ET. Current knowledge along with our new findings in patients with ET-possibly arising from individually unrecognised extremely mild, cognitive difficulties-should help in designing specific rehabilitative programmes to improve cognitive and behavioural disturbances in patients.