Introduction The high-risk critically ill are exposed to signifi cant stressors, along with diffi culties in communicating them to relatives and members of the staff . The aim of this study was to compare the perception of stressors as reported by patients (P), relatives (R) and ICU staff members (S). Methods A validated questionnaire [1] was used to quantitatively assess discomforts related to the ICU stay. Items were clustered into categories; higher scores refer to a higher stressfulness. The median (IQR) was calculated for each category. Twenty-eight high-risk critically ill at discharge, 55 relatives 48 hours after admission of their next of kin, and a total of 125 staff members (55 attending physicians, 40 nurses and 30 medical students/specialist trainees) were interviewed. Fifty-six of the staff members were used to keep patients consciously sedated as for local guidelines; the remaining used deeper levels of sedation. Nonparametric tests were used as needed. Results All stressor categories were diff erently reported by the three groups analysed: environmental (S = 17 (15 to 19), R = 15 (13 to 18), P = 10 (8 to 11), P <0.01), relationships (S = 23 (21 to 25), R = 20.5 (17 to 24.5), P = 14 (11 to 17), P <0.01), emotional (S = 25.5 (23 to 28), R = 24 (20 to 26), P = 18 (15 to 22), P <0.01), and physical (S = 35 (31 to 38), R = 33 (26.5 to 37), P = 27 (21 to 30), P <0.01). Among the staff members, nurses overestimated more than attending physicians, while trainees are closer to relatives’ perception (P = 0.03). Staff members used to conscious sedation overestimate less the impact of environmental stressors (P = 0.03). Years of experience (r = 0.24, P = 0.03) and age (r = 0.27, P = 0.01) are related to stressor overestimation among staff members. Conclusion Members of the staff should reconsider their beliefs on patients’ perception of stressors. We argue that such an overestimation may bring inappropriate administration of analgesic and sedative drugs, particularly for nurses and older members of staff . Relatives might be useful intermediaries to have a better insight of patients’ perception.

Stressors in the ICU : different perceptions of patients, relatives and staff members / M. Umbrello, G. Mistraletti, B. Cerri, E. Carloni, V. Mariani, A. Di Carlo, F. Martinetti, L. D’Amato, S. Miori, G. Iapichino. ((Intervento presentato al 32. convegno ISICEM, International Symposium on Intensive Care and Emergency Medicine tenutosi a Bruxelles nel 2012.

Stressors in the ICU : different perceptions of patients, relatives and staff members

M. Umbrello
Primo
;
G. Mistraletti
Secondo
;
E. Carloni;S. Miori
Penultimo
;
G. Iapichino
Ultimo
2012

Abstract

Introduction The high-risk critically ill are exposed to signifi cant stressors, along with diffi culties in communicating them to relatives and members of the staff . The aim of this study was to compare the perception of stressors as reported by patients (P), relatives (R) and ICU staff members (S). Methods A validated questionnaire [1] was used to quantitatively assess discomforts related to the ICU stay. Items were clustered into categories; higher scores refer to a higher stressfulness. The median (IQR) was calculated for each category. Twenty-eight high-risk critically ill at discharge, 55 relatives 48 hours after admission of their next of kin, and a total of 125 staff members (55 attending physicians, 40 nurses and 30 medical students/specialist trainees) were interviewed. Fifty-six of the staff members were used to keep patients consciously sedated as for local guidelines; the remaining used deeper levels of sedation. Nonparametric tests were used as needed. Results All stressor categories were diff erently reported by the three groups analysed: environmental (S = 17 (15 to 19), R = 15 (13 to 18), P = 10 (8 to 11), P <0.01), relationships (S = 23 (21 to 25), R = 20.5 (17 to 24.5), P = 14 (11 to 17), P <0.01), emotional (S = 25.5 (23 to 28), R = 24 (20 to 26), P = 18 (15 to 22), P <0.01), and physical (S = 35 (31 to 38), R = 33 (26.5 to 37), P = 27 (21 to 30), P <0.01). Among the staff members, nurses overestimated more than attending physicians, while trainees are closer to relatives’ perception (P = 0.03). Staff members used to conscious sedation overestimate less the impact of environmental stressors (P = 0.03). Years of experience (r = 0.24, P = 0.03) and age (r = 0.27, P = 0.01) are related to stressor overestimation among staff members. Conclusion Members of the staff should reconsider their beliefs on patients’ perception of stressors. We argue that such an overestimation may bring inappropriate administration of analgesic and sedative drugs, particularly for nurses and older members of staff . Relatives might be useful intermediaries to have a better insight of patients’ perception.
mar-2012
Settore MED/41 - Anestesiologia
Stressors in the ICU : different perceptions of patients, relatives and staff members / M. Umbrello, G. Mistraletti, B. Cerri, E. Carloni, V. Mariani, A. Di Carlo, F. Martinetti, L. D’Amato, S. Miori, G. Iapichino. ((Intervento presentato al 32. convegno ISICEM, International Symposium on Intensive Care and Emergency Medicine tenutosi a Bruxelles nel 2012.
Conference Object
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.
Pubblicazioni consigliate

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/2434/172762
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact